Join today get up to 75% OFF for the first 3 months!*

Contractor vs Employee: Understanding the differences, benefits & tax implications

Contractor vs employee differences

In the small business world, understanding the difference between hiring an independent contractor versus an employee is important. This article will help you cover the key differences, benefits, and tax implications to help you make informed decisions and focus on what matters most—growing your business while employing the right people. 

What is a Contractor?

Contractors, sometimes referred to as consultants, are self-employed individuals engaged in specific tasks at an agreed price with a particular goal in mind, often over a set period. They set their own working hours and are paid a fee for completing each assignment, not a salary or wage. Once a project/assignment is completed, a contractor can move on to a new project/assignment with a different business and can work for multiple businesses simultaneously.

Independent contractors are effectively treated as small businesses or sole traders, which has various tax implications. Among these are self-managing GST registration and payments, as well as paying income taxes rather than having them deducted by employers.

What is an Employee?

An employee is an individual who works for a business and is an integral part of that organisation. Unlike contractors, employees have a more structured working relationship with their employer, typically working set hours and receiving a regular salary or wage.

The business provides employees with the necessary tools and resources to perform their job duties. However, employees are not free to delegate their tasks to others and must follow their employer’s directions and guidelines.

From a tax perspective, employees have their income tax deducted directly from their pay by the employer. Additionally, they receive compulsory superannuation contributions and are entitled to various benefits such as sick leave, annual leave, and long service leave. The business bears the legal responsibility for the work performed by the employee and must ensure compliance with all relevant employment laws and regulations.

Why do businesses prefer contractors?

Businesses often prefer contractors because they offer significant financial flexibility. They can hire and let go contractors as needed to manage workload fluctuations, save on expenses, and reduce red tape.

The preference can change depending on the industry. For example, employees and contractors in the design industry can sometimes value freedom over the benefits of being a salaried employee. Contractors can also be popular for construction payroll, since work comes at a by-project basis. 

Contractors can select their clients, set their own hours, and determine their rates. For disciplined workers, this can be an excellent option. However, it also means less job security, no access to traditional employee rights, and more administrative work.

What are the differences between an independent contractor vs. employee?

Distinguishing between an employee and a contractor is extremely important due to significant tax implications. When an individual is engaged solely for their labour, they are generally considered an employee rather than a contractor.

Misclassification can result in liabilities for unpaid superannuation, payroll tax, and penalties. Ensuring correct classification helps maintain compliance with ATO regulations and avoids legal and financial issues.

Here’s a summary of the differences between being an employee and a contractor:

Works in the business and is part of the organisationRuns their own business and provides services to other businesses
Cannot subcontract or delegate their workCan subcontract or delegate their work
Paid for time worked, per item or activity, or commissionPaid for a result achieved based on a provided quote
The business provides tools and equipment or reimburses costsProvides their own tools and equipment with no reimbursement
Takes no commercial risks; the business is legally responsibleTakes commercial risks and is legally responsible for their work
Business directs how the work is performedHas control over how the work is done within the terms of the contract
Does not operate independently; part of the businessOperates independently; not part of the business
The employer deducts taxPays their own tax from gross earnings
Receives superannuation contributions from employerMust make their own superannuation contributions
Entitled to employee benefits (sick leave, annual leave)Not entitled to employee benefits

Benefits of hiring an employee

Greater control and integration

Employees become part of your team, allowing for better training, supervision, and alignment with your company culture. You have more control over their work methods and direction.

Long-term commitment and stability

Employees provide a stable workforce for ongoing tasks and projects. Their knowledge and experience accumulated over time, benefiting your company’s long-term goals.

Access to benefits and perks

Employees are typically eligible for benefits like health insurance, paid leave, and retirement plans, which can be attractive for attracting and retaining talent.

Ownership and accountability

Employees often have a stronger sense of ownership over their work, leading to higher engagement and accountability for results.

Benefits of hiring a contractor

More cost-effective for employers

Contractors are typically hired for a specific project or timeframe, so you only pay sole traders, freelancers, or contractors for the work they do. There are no additional costs associated with contractor payroll taxes, benefits, or overhead.

Specialised skills and expertise

Contractors often bring specialised skills and experience to the table, allowing you to access expertise you might not have in-house. This is ideal for short-term projects requiring specific knowledge.

Better flexibility and scalability

Hiring contractors provides flexibility to adjust your workforce based on project needs. You can easily scale up or down without the commitment of a permanent employee.

Reduced administrative burden

You don’t have to handle payroll taxes, benefits administration, or performance reviews for contractors, freeing up your time and resources.

How to know if you should hire an employee or a contractor

When it comes to getting things done, both employees and contractors offer advantages and disadvantages, so the best choice depends on the specific needs of your project or business.

For long-term ongoing tasks, employees are better suited. For one-time projects, hiring skilled and experienced contractors may be more cost-efficient, especially when additional training would be necessary for employees.

Contractor fees are a more predictable expense depending on which of the services you utilise. Employee benefits add to the overall cost of labour, but they largely improve employee satisfaction and help retain workers who can grow with your business. The level of control and integration with your team culture is also higher with employees.

Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific needs and priorities. Consider all the factors involved to make an informed decision that benefits both your project and your business.

Tax implications for contractor or employee

Differences in tax obligations between employees and contractors

There are significant differences between tax obligations for employees and contractors:

Employees’ tax obligations

  • Tax is deducted from their salary by the employer.
  • Receive compulsory superannuation payments from their employer.
  • Minimal personal tax administration.

Contractors’ tax obligations

  • Responsible for paying their own tax from gross earnings.
  • Must make their own superannuation contributions.
  • Need to manage their own GST registration and payments if applicable.
  • Can claim business expenses as deductions.

The consequences of misclassification

The Fair Work Act prohibits “sham contracting arrangements,” where workers are wrongly labelled as independent contractors to avoid providing employee entitlements. Violations of superannuation and workers’ compensation laws can result in tax evasion and prosecution.

ATO + Fair Work

Ready to simplify your payroll process? Sign up for Payroller today and experience the difference firsthand!

Visit our website to get started.

Tax rates for contractors and employees

The income tax rates for independent contractors and employees in Australia are the same, based on the ATO’s progressive tax system. Here are the tax rates for the 2023-2024 tax year:

Taxable incomeTax on this income
0 – $18,200Nil
$18,201 – $45,00019c for each $1 over $18,200
$45,001 – $120,000$5,092 plus 32.5c for each $1 over $45,000
$120,001 – $180,000$29,467 plus 37c for each $1 over $120,000
$180,001 and over$51,667 plus 45c for each $1 over $180,000

Ensuring compliance for contractors and employees on your payroll

It’s the hiring company’s responsibility to ensure the worker is classified correctly. If a business incorrectly classifies a contractor instead of an employee, it is obligated to account for PAYG on wages, pay superannuation, and provide entitlements like annual leave and long service leave.

Ensuring your employees are correctly classified is crucial for understanding rights and obligations. Whether you decide to hire an independent contractor or an employee, it’s essential to be informed and compliant with relevant laws and regulations. 

With Payroller, you can streamline your payroll process, save valuable time, and ensure compliance with tax regulations. Sign up today and discover the ease and efficiency of managing your payroll with Payroller.

Payroll made accessible.

Create your free account now.

*By clicking “Try For Free“, you agree to our terms of services and privacy policy.